At a Conference on Migration held in Vienna (Austria) on November 16 and 17, 2026, five European countries (Germany, Austria, Denmark, Greece, and the Netherlands) announced their intention to soon open in Rwanda a centre for migrants expelled from Europe. Starting in 2027, this centre will accommodate around 100 migrants whose asylum applications have been rejected and who, having exhausted all appeal options in one of the concerned countries, cannot or do not want to be returned to their countries of origin.
This new migration policy, welcomed by European institutions, is framed by the new European return regulation (EU) 2026/2280, adopted a few months ago. It allows member states to create return hubs in third countries but stipulates that such agreements can only be made with countries that comply with international standards, which is notoriously far from being the case for Paul Kagame’s Rwanda. The project’s initiators respond to critics that the intended effect is deterrent: it’s supposed to discourage illegal migrants who want to rush into Europe.
A new era of human trafficking
According to the Dutch government, the first phase of pushbacks to Rwanda will only involve single men. The Netherlands also says it prefers expelling to Rwanda nationals from countries located in the same region as that country.
Within Rwanda, migrants unwanted in Europe will be taken care of by the country’s authorities, housed in Welcome centres, and given a residence permit. But neither the five European countries behind this controversial project nor the Rwandan government says a word about what the Rwandan military-led principality will get in return for taking on this modern-day slaver role. The plan to expel migrants to Rwanda is, as expected, widely criticized, especially by human rights organizations, many of which have voiced vehement protests, because by deciding to transfer people who have been denied asylum outside the European Union, the five countries that still claim to uphold the 1951 Convention and the Convention Against Torture are deliberately sacrificing the values they have imposed for decades all over the world in the name of universal human rights. In this case, it’s the principle of not sending someone to a place where they risk persecution, torture, or inhumane treatment, including through a later transfer to another country, that is being casually ignored.
A shocking arbitrariness
Beyond this legal aspect, the plan to transfer rejected migrants to Rwanda is questionable on several levels. In principle, European migration policy is meant to address the problem of massive arrivals of migrants on the old continent, but the announced measure is justified by the authors’ will to discourage those still in Africa who might be thinking of going to Europe, which suggests a cynical objectification of human beings. Indeed, a human being is thus reduced to a lever, a mere instrument of socio-political communication. The whole exercise boils down to sending a hundred innocent people to the Rwandan hell to discourage a few others from trying to disrupt the peace of taxpayers in these five European countries.
We can notice glaring conceptual contradictions in the project. In January 2026, during the UN review of the human rights situation in Rwanda, Germany, Greece, Denmark, and the Netherlands had expressed serious concerns about detention conditions and the lack of independence of the Rwandan human rights institution. Eleven months earlier (February 2025), the European Parliament had passed a resolution urging the European Union to freeze its direct budgetary aid to Rwanda and to suspend a minerals agreement as long as the country did not end its direct involvement in the war in neighbouring DRC. As a result, Germany had scaled back its bilateral aid to Rwanda that same year. Under these circumstances, one can only be surprised by the sudden blank check that the five EU countries give to the criminal and predatory ethnocracy in power in Kigali through this ‘sui generis’ migration policy, because Rwanda is anything but a safe country for anyone.
Blatant contradictions
In any case, in November 2023, just three years ago, the UK Supreme Court ruled that Rwanda was not a safe third country to send migrants to, and that there were serious reasons to fear that asylum seekers might be roughly sent back to their home countries. These weren’t empty words. The highest British judicial institution based its claims on the experience of the agreement between Rwanda and Israel from 2013 to 2018. The Rwandan government had not honoured its non-refoulement commitments even though they were made in writing. “Diplomatic assurances from a government are only worth the rule of law that guarantees them,” commented a British human rights activist. Many reports from international organizations confirm that President Paul Kagame and his associates have little regard for life, human dignity, and human rights in general. The 2026 Human Rights Watch World Report notes that until 2025, Rwanda continued its policy of repressing political opposition both within the country and abroad. The report also links his massive military support to the M23 and the control he exerts over this armed group in eastern DRC to serious abuses. The previous year, the organization pointed out that torture was very common in the countless detention centres across the country. It also noted that the 2024 presidential election, won by Paul Kagame with 99.15% of the vote, took place against a backdrop of repression, as a reminder.
People transferred to Rwanda are therefore handed over, bound hand and foot, to a judicial system that cannot guarantee their protection. There’s a risk that they could be sent to places where they might suffer serious harm, as well as risks of arbitrary detention, refoulement, and limited access to a fair trial and legal remedies. In this regard, Clémentine de Montjoye, a senior researcher in HRW’s Africa division, has serious doubts about the possibility of successfully integrating those sent back to Rwanda. She also reminds Europeans that Rwanda has already taken part in three programs set up by other governments to get rid of people they no longer wanted. Each of these programs raised serious human rights concerns.
Concerns of the African Commission on Human Rights
The migrant reception project negotiated with Kigali is causing serious concern for the African Commission on Human Rights established by the African Union. In a statement published on November 18, 2026, it said that “the arrangements being considered raise serious concerns about the protection of the fundamental rights of the people involved, including risks of refoulement, arbitrary detention, denial of access to effective protection procedures, and their transfer to a third country with which they may have no prior connection.” It also noted that the exercise of powers related to the sovereign right of states to define their migration policies and to enter into international cooperation agreements “remains subject to compliance with their international and regional obligations regarding human rights and the protection of refugees, asylum seekers and migrants. In particular, migration cooperation must not aim to or result in circumventing, transferring, or weakening the fundamental guarantees recognized for migrants, refugees, and asylum seekers’’. Kigali doesn’t really bother with this, as it ignores Resolution ACHPR/Res.645 (LXXXV) 2025 on the obligations of African states in the context of policies outsourcing migrant governance and extra-regional transfers of migrants to Africa. This decision calls on African states to ensure transparency in migration agreements made or planned with non-African countries and to avoid partnerships that carry a real risk of serious human rights violations.
The tree that hides the forest
The lack of transparency regarding the expected payoff for Rwanda from this migrant transfer project is the tree that clumsily hides the forest. This payoff is political, just as the European Union has already done with the blood-critical minerals from the DRC: having rejected migrants in Europe subcontracted by Rwanda. For the Rwandan ethnocracy, migration is not a humanitarian issue. It’s a geopolitical lever. As the Rwandan journalist in exile, Samuel Baker Biansi, writes, ‘‘As soon as a return centre is considered, any potential sanction is weighed against the risk that Kigali might close the door – whether it’s about M23, the presence of 14,000 to 18,000 soldiers in Kivu, the looting of Congolese mineral resources, or transnational repression.’’
Having become Europe’s migrant subcontractor, Rwanda holds formidable leverage. Which signatory government would still dare to demand the release of opposition leader Victoire Ingabire, denounce trials and killings of opponents, or support sanctions against Rwandan sponsorship of armed groups in the DRC, at the risk of seeing Kigali threaten to suspend the agreement? The dependence is reversed: it’s Europe that ends up being indebted to Kagame. The European migration imperatives thus end up reinforcing a repressive power that believes it can continue its abuses without consequences, according to analysts.
Through the new migrant transfer project, Kigali is aiming to accumulate enough bricks of dependency and indispensability to paralyze, when the time comes, any attempt to impose or support sanctions against its criminal blunders in Congolese territory.
Lambert Mende Omalanga
National Deputy of the DRC (External Relations Committee)